California's Drought: We’re All in This Together
As California endures its fourth straight year of severe drought, anxiety about our water supply intensifies. The members of the California Roundtable on Agriculture and the Environment (CRAE) - a forum for dialogue among agricultural, environmental, and governmental leaders—ask our fellow Californians to adopt a fresh perspective.
Media coverage about the current California drought has been extensive. Unfortunately, it has often oversimplified the realities of the California water system. Recent headlines have been fraught with finger-pointing across sectors about who’s to blame for our state water crisis. The resulting polarization of urban, agricultural, and environmental interests tends to drive these groups to their respective corners, where we are each encouraged to commiserate and launch counter attacks, rather than find common ground and collaborate on solutions in service of the greater public interest.
As representatives of agricultural, environmental, and government interests, the members of CRAE call for a different response. After much candid discussion, we have come to realize three things that we have not been hearing:
Blame is not a productive response;
- We are all part of an interdependent system, experiencing this problem together; and
- To move toward solutions, we must talk with and not at each other, and be willing to work collaboratively.
From this unified place, we urge all Californians to see the water crisis as our shared problem. When it doesn’t rain or snow, there are devastating consequences for agriculture, fish and wildlife, and the economy. In the current drought, actions have already been taken on all fronts. Let’s shift our focus from debate and vilification toward dialogue and developing the cooperative and innovative solutions necessary to ensure the long-term viability of California’s communities, agriculture, environment, and water supply.
As we navigate this drought, we must also recognize that water supply problems are likely to become more common in California. Shifting climate patterns, a growing population, and degraded ecosystems, all contribute to an increasingly challenging future.
Achieving long-term drought resilience that will help us better cope with the future droughts we know will come requires acknowledging a few key truths:
- California’s unique climate and geography make it home to plants and animals that exist nowhere else on earth, and also make it possible to grow many crops that do not grow well in other parts of the country.
- A healthy environment is essential to a healthy economy—and to the quality of life for all Californians.
- Farms and ranches rely on the environment—including land and water—to produce food and fiber.
- Working lands can, and often do, provide important public benefits such as wildlife habitat, carbon sequestration, groundwater recharge, flood risk management, and beauty.
- Sustainable water management can only occur when we reduce conflicts between our human and ecological systems and identify opportunities to help both to thrive.
Although we may ultimately have less water than we are accustomed to, we can better address all of California’s water needs if we work together using our full toolkit of water management practices with a focus on developing solutions that deliver multiple benefits.
Examples of collaborative solutions exist in California and beyond. These include the “One Water, One Watershed” plan, which fosters long-term collaboration among diverse stakeholders in the Santa Ana Watershed, and the Nigiri Project at Knaggs Ranch, which is managed for the multiple benefits of rice production, habitat for native fish and waterfowl, and flood risk management. We can learn from countries as far away as Australia or Israel or our neighboring states of Colorado and New Mexico, where leaders have struggled with similar crises and found win-win solutions for cities, agriculture, and the environment.
By focusing on how we might work together rather than who’s to blame, we can all come to the table and find solutions for better stewarding our water supply. We are all affected and we must all contribute. We are all in this together.
This statement was produced and is supported by the undersigned members of the California Roundtable on Agriculture and the Environment (CRAE):
- Agricultural Council of California
- Almond Board of California
- American Farmland Trust
- Audubon California
- California Association of Resource Conservation Districts
- California Climate & Agriculture Network
- California Fresh Fruit Association
- Community Alliance with Family Farmers
- Defenders of Wildlife
- Environmental Defense Fund
- Markon Cooperative
- The Nature Conservancy
- Sacramento San Joaquin Delta Conservancy
- San Joaquin Resource Conservation District
- Sustainable Conservation
- Corny Gallagher, SVP, Food, Ag, and Wine Executive, Bank of America Merrill Lynch
- Douglas McGehee, SVP Senior Credit Products Officer, Bank of America Merrill Lynch
- Holly King, King-Gardiner Farms, LLC
- Paul Martin, Martin Family Ranch
- Richard Rominger, Rominger Brothers Farms
- Robert J. Gore, Silent Partner Strategies
Special thanks to CRAE’s institutional members for their participation in the development of this statement:
- California Department of Conservation
- California Department of Food and Agriculture
- University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources
- University of California at Davis College of Agriculture and Environmental Science
- USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service
- State Water Resources Control Board
Since 2004, the California Roundtable on Agriculture and the Environment (CRAE) has served as a forum for agricultural, environmental, and government leaders to resolve conflict, find common ground, and work together to support agriculture and improve environmental outcomes. Convened by Ag Innovations, the group has provided policy insight on many key issues in the state. Visit www.aginnovations.org/crae for more information.
- We're Hiring! Seeking a Talented Senior Facilitator to round out our team!
- We're Hiring: Senior Facilitator
- Current Ag Innovations Roundtables and Projects:
- Systems Thinking for Intractable Problems: From Problem-Solving to Emergence-Seeking
- From Forests to Farms: a Learning Journey with California Water Action Collaborative (CWAC)
- When Water Works with Fire: FireSmart Lake Sonoma
- Leaders Convene to Discuss the Future California Bioeconomy
- Cultivating California’s Bioeconomy: Turning Ag Waste Into Profit
- Santa Barbara County Food Action Plan Released
- Longstanding CRAE Member, Richard Rominger, Awarded UC Davis's Highest Award
- 200+ Leaders Convene for 2016 Sonoma County Food Forum
- Purple Wheat: Growing a New Food System Collaboratively
Recent Related Projects
Firesmart Lake Sonoma Watershed Project
In the Summer and Fall of 2018 Ag Innovations and Sonoma County Water Agency (Sonoma Water) partnered to a two-part workshop series called "FireSmart Lake Sonoma" about living with fire in the Lake Sonoma Watershed. If a catastrophic fire were to occur in the Lake Sonoma Watershed, it could lead to contamination of the region’s drinking water supply, affecting over 600,000 residents. We are committed to working together on solutions to better protect your home and our primary regional water source. Lake Sonoma watershed has three distinct communities, connected by major roadways and divided by the lake. With this in mind we hosted a two-part workshop on reducing fire risk and increasing fire resiliency in the Lake Sonoma Watershed.
This project is a Resilient Community Pilot Project funded by PG&E Resilient Communities Better Together 2017 grant and the Sonoma County Water Agency.
Sustainable Agricultural Lands Conservation (SALC) Program
In Santa Clara County (County) the time is now to align the myriad of plans, programs, policies and infrastructure investments affecting undeveloped agricultural lands across this rapidly growing County and its Cities to sustain the Valley’s natural environment, support the local agricultural economy, maintain the health of its communities and increase the resiliency and adaptation of this region in the face of climate change.
Sustainable Groundwater Management Program in Solano County
The Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA) established a robust framework for the sustainable management of groundwater resources for the first time in California’s history. The first step in implementing SGMA is to develop Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs), a focal point of local public agencies and stakeholders at this time. Ag Innovations is supporting the GSA formation process for two GSAs in the Solano Subbasin, primarily located in Solano County, by offering a range of professional services, including process design, facilitation, research and analysis.
“Ag Innovations has done a great job of mediating between agricultural and environmental interests to help them find common ground on controversial issues.”